Asynchronous vs. Synchronous Generators: Choosing the Right Option for Small Hydroelectric Plants

Vili Matošević

Electrical machines, Synchronous Generator

September 1, 2024

Asynchronous vs. Synchronous Generators: Choosing the Right Option for Small Hydroelectric Plants ​

Introduction: ​

When planning a small hydroelectric plant, one of the most crucial decisions you’ll face is the choice of generator type: asynchronous (induction) or synchronous. Each type has its own set of advantages and challenges, which can significantly impact the efficiency, cost, and overall performance of your plant. Whether you prioritize cost-effectiveness, grid compatibility, or operational stability, understanding the key differences between these two types of generators is essential for making an informed decision. In this article, we’ll explore the critical factors that should guide your choice, ensuring your small hydroelectric project operates at its best.

This table now includes a detailed comparison across various important criteria, offering a clear guide for choosing between asynchronous and synchronous generators based on specific needs.

Criterion Asynchronous Generator Synchronous Generator Better Choice
Efficiency
Lower
Higher
Synchronous Generator
Cost
Lower
Higher
Asynchronous Generator
Design Simplicity
Simpler
More Complex
Asynchronous Generator
Speed Control
Limited
Precise
Synchronous Generator
Voltage Stability
Lower
Higher
Synchronous Generator
Power Factor Performance
Poor, generally lagging
Can be controlled, leading or lagging
Synchronous Generator
Overspeed Performance
Better
Sensitive
Asynchronous Generator
Voltage Control (AVR)
Not available
Available
Synchronous Generator
Synchronization
Not required
Required
Asynchronous Generator
Load Capability
Less stable under varying load
Stable under varying load
Synchronous Generator
Overload Capability
Limited
Better, can handle short periods of overload
Synchronous Generator
Grid Usage
Often as a motor
Often as a generator
Depends on Application
Installation and Maintenance
Easier
More Complex
Asynchronous Generator
Capital Costs
Lower
Higher
Asynchronous Generator
Operation under Variable Load
Poorer
Better
Synchronous Generator

Explanation:

  • Power Factor Performance: Ability to manage the power factor; synchronous generators can adjust their power factor, while asynchronous generators typically have a fixed, lagging power factor.
  • Overspeed Performance: How well the generator handles situations when the speed exceeds the rated value; asynchronous generators generally handle overspeed better.
  • Voltage Control (AVR): Availability of Automatic Voltage Regulation; only synchronous generators typically have AVR.
  • Synchronization: Whether synchronization with the grid is required; synchronous generators need synchronization, while asynchronous generators do not.
  • Load Capability: Stability of the generator under varying load conditions.
  • Overload Capability: The ability to handle temporary overloads; synchronous generators generally perform better in this aspect, being able to handle short periods of overload without significant issues.

 

Key Factors in Choosing Between Asynchronous and Synchronous Generators for Small Hydroelectric Plants ​

The choice between an asynchronous (induction) generator and a synchronous generator for a small hydroelectric plant primarily depends on several key factors:

  1. Grid Connection Requirements: If the small hydroelectric plant needs to be synchronized with the grid, a synchronous generator is usually preferred due to its ability to precisely control the frequency and voltage. Asynchronous generators, while simpler, do not have this control and are typically used in grid-independent applications or where grid synchronization is managed externally.

  2. Cost and Simplicity: Asynchronous generators are generally cheaper and simpler to install and maintain. For small, cost-sensitive projects where grid synchronization is not a priority, an asynchronous generator might be more suitable.

  3. Power Factor and Efficiency: Synchronous generators offer better control over the power factor, which can improve the overall efficiency of the plant. In contrast, asynchronous generators typically operate at a lagging power factor, which may require additional equipment like capacitors to correct.

  4. Load Variability: Synchronous generators handle load variability better, maintaining stable voltage and frequency even under changing load conditions. If the hydro plant experiences significant load variations, a synchronous generator would likely be the better choice.

  5. Overload Capability: Synchronous generators have a better overload capability, allowing them to handle temporary overloads more effectively, which can be important in scenarios where the load may occasionally exceed the nominal capacity.

In summary, the decision depends on the specific operational requirements of the hydroelectric plant, with grid connection, cost, power factor, load variability, and overload capability being the primary considerations.

Recent articles

Data to be checked when replacing the AVR